May 19, 2026 — Arkville, NY: The Catskill Center for Conservation and Development has submitted formal comments to the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation on the Kaaterskill Clove Project Area Visitor Use Management Pilot Project Final Recommendations Report and Monitoring Plan, urging the state to pursue active management, safety improvements, and stronger regional coordination before considering any restrictions on public access.
The Catskill Center said it strongly supports DEC’s use of the Visitor Use Management, or VUM, framework at Kaaterskill Clove and views the report as an important step toward implementing recommendations from the Catskill Advisory Group for more active management of high-use areas in the Catskill Park. At the same time, the organization’s comments make clear that capping daily visitors or relying on permits at Kaaterskill Falls would be the wrong starting point for one of the Catskills’ most iconic and historically significant public destinations.
“Kaaterskill Clove is one of the defining landscapes of the Catskills, and it deserves thoughtful, data-driven management that protects both the resource and the public’s ability to experience it,” said Jeff Senterman, Executive Director of the Catskill Center. “Our comments urge DEC to focus first on the many tools available to improve safety, reduce congestion, strengthen stewardship, and better manage visitor flow before turning to measures that would limit public access.”
In its comments, the Catskill Center emphasizes that Kaaterskill Clove is not only a sensitive natural landscape, but also one of the birthplaces of Catskills tourism and a major economic driver for surrounding communities. The organization argues that a successful long-term strategy must reflect both realities by balancing conservation, public access, visitor safety, and community needs.
Among the Catskill Center’s key recommendations are:
More staffing for visitor education, information, and enforcement throughout Kaaterskill Falls and the broader Clove, including expansion of the Catskill Stewards Program.
Infrastructure improvements such as better parking design, signage, trail connections, viewing areas, and circulation patterns to spread use more safely and sustainably.
Real-time communication to visitors about parking conditions, crowding, and trail access before they arrive, using tools recommended in the Catskill Advisory Group report.
A broader regional approach that includes a strategic transportation plan for the Route 23A corridor and serious evaluation of a multi-destination seasonal shuttle system.
Close collaboration among DEC, the Department of Transportation, the Town of Hunter, Greene County, the Mountain Top Historical Society, the Catskill Center, and other regional partners.
The comments also warn that access restrictions at Kaaterskill Falls could push visitors into nearby areas that are less prepared for additional use, including other parts of the Kaaterskill Clove corridor and neighboring destinations. The Catskill Center argues that any serious consideration of a permit system should first include a careful review of how the Blue Hole permit system has worked, along with an economic impact analysis for Hunter and surrounding communities.
The Catskill Center has long advocated for intensive management in high-use areas of the Catskill Park and has supported VUM planning in both Kaaterskill Clove and the formerly trailless Catskill High Peaks. In its newly submitted comments, the organization says Kaaterskill can become a model for how to manage heavy visitation without unnecessarily closing off access to one of New York’s most celebrated public landscapes.
“The question is not whether Kaaterskill Clove needs stronger management. It does,” Senterman said. “The question is whether we are willing to fully invest in staffing, infrastructure, communications, transportation planning, and regional partnership before concluding that the answer is to turn people away.”
The Catskill Center’s comments were submitted to DEC on May 18, 2026. A copy of the submitted letter is available from the Catskill Center.